A Mark In Time
Mark Knopfler Discussion => Mark Knopfler Discussion Forum => Topic started by: stefankock on April 19, 2014, 05:30:01 PM
-
Hello everyone,
Not much of of a poster, and even less of a topic starter, but lately I have begun listening more and more to Eric Clapton. For some reason Eric's playing didn't do it for me, but now I'm really 'into' it, although Mark stays my #1 guitar player.
I've noticed that Eric on some tours starts, or has, an acoustic section in his show as opposite to Mark who playes acoustic songs throughout the whole concert. I've noticed that I liked the acoustic songs better when they were played as a section (I normally don't care for acoustic guitar playing) and thought about what it would be like when Mark would do the same.
What are your thoughts and opinions about that ? If you think that adding a 'seperate' acoustic section' into the concert, what songs would you like to hear played and in which place should the acoustic section be (beginning, middle, end) ?
I also noticed that Eric has done / does both acoustic and electric versions of certain songs (Layla, Driftin' , etc ) ..... could that also work for Mark ?? Would be great to hear an electric version of for example 'Get Lucky' ....
-
Mark did a similar thing with a semi-acoustic section after Sultans on the SL tour in 2005. They brought out a chair for him and Richard too (I think), took a cup of tea (maybe beer actually) and played about four songs:
Bonaparte
Sonny Liston
R
-
Mark did a similar thing with a semi-acoustic section after Sultans on the SL tour in 2005. They brought out a chair for him and Richard too (I think), took a cup of tea (maybe beer actually) and played about four songs:
Bonaparte
Sonny Liston
R
-
The closest thing would have been the Boothbay concert, but even there he "only" dispensed with the drums... I guess it will not happen - he has always the electric in reach...
I like the idea on the last sets that he always has a little three-piece (Sonny Liston) or four-piece (Sultans, Gator Blood) in his set. That's his kind of stripping down the set. And finally: The live versions of the Get Lucky track were all pretty bad in 2010 in my opinion, he just cannot sing that song live. It is not enough for the big halls..
LE
-
I have dreamed for years that MK would do an unplugged concert. Not only songs that they are originally played acoustic on albums, but also other songs which can give a fresh feeling, like SFA Sydney 86, Water of Love NHB version, and so on. I know certain electric songs apparently do not fit playing acoustic, but still there are lots to choose.
Wishes
Allen
-
I think that an MK acoustic set would be fantastic because it would give him and us a chance to revisit some older and rarely heard songs. WWE or Lions, News or Follow me home come to mind. And maybe he can do it within a TV special program, like MTV unplugged, like Clapton, or lately Scorpions (The avatar photo is from Lycabetus theater that MK has played in 2008, but the very photo is from Scorpions unplugged 3 day gigs - 2 were recorded for MTV one was for fans, from 2013)
-
He does an acoustic set, but with just one song that last the same of three or four regular songs, you know Marbletown...
-
He does an acoustic set, but with just one song that last the same of three or four regular songs, you know Marbletown...
Privateering? :)
-
He does an acoustic set, but with just one song that last the same of three or four regular songs, you know Marbletown...
Privateering? :)
Different sections during the concert ;D
-
He does an acoustic set, but with just one song that last the same of three or four regular songs, you know Marbletown...
We need a Loooooooooong set, at least more than 10. :D
-
How long lasts Marbletown? Do it longer and DMG will kill himself during it :lol
-
Mark in his past life has already extended TOL to over 22 minutes. I have no doubt that he could success doing the same with Marbletown.
Clapton also did it mid 80's with Same Old Blues and it was boring to death, showing how surprisingly weak Mark could be soloing on a slow blues stuff.
Hopefully when last time they reunited on stage to perform it again it was back to a perfect 7 minutes format.
Mark should think about it for Marbletown ;)
Shorter but stronger.
-
Mark in his past life has already extended TOL to over 22 minutes. I have no doubt that he could success doing the same with Marbletown.
Clapton also did it mid 80's with Same Old Blues and it was boring to death, showing how surprisingly weak Mark could be soloing on a slow blues stuff.
Hopefully when last time they reunited on stage to perform it again it was back to a perfect 7 minutes format.
Mark should think about it for Marbletown ;)
Shorter but stronger.
I worried for a moment about where you were going with this but finally you started to make sense! ;D
-
For me, Marbletown is indeed the highpoint of the show (and not Telegraph Road), and I really loved it from the first time they played it live in 2008.
But I agree that last year's versions were indeed a little bit too long - John McCusker got too much room for his fiddle picking, and I never got what was so great about him picking together with Glen Worf - that part was too long. And in the last weeks of the tour, they even made the very last final part even longer. Although I love the development of Jim Cox playing more plinki-plink-piano at the end, quite jazzy...
So to sum it up, the 2010 versions were the best ones. From my point of view, he should play Calling Elvis again and extend it to around 15 minutes.. ;D
LE
-
An acoustic Calling Elvis with endless fiddle, flute and plinky piano would be a dream come true ;D
-
An acoustic set would be enjoyable. Which songs would be your "top 5"? I would def like f.ex Wild West End, Devil Baby, Water of Love, Miss you Blues and How Long..
-
"Where do you think you're going" :clap
-
The man'd too strong. Love Over Gold. Iron Hand. Where do you think you're going? Golden Heart. Going Home.
-
What do you mean with acoustic set? Playing with acoustic (guitars and basses like Clapton in MTV unplugged) and with a small drum set and no keyboards or full band with very stripped off performance? Or electric guitar song turned to played with acoustics?
-
Done with Bonaparte.
LE
-
The acoustic set will be filled with one third of next album.
-
Oooh imagine MK doing a MTV Unplugged-like concert :D :D
My (realistic?) set for that, just MK and Richard and Glenn:
01. Camerado
02. 5:15 AM
03. Sailing To Philadelphia
04. Redbud Tree
05. The Trawlerman's Song
06. Golden Heart
07. Romeo & Juliet
08. Song For Sonny Liston
09. Monteleone
10. Back To Tupelo
11. A Place Where We Used To Live
12. Postcards From Paraguay
13. The Long Road
14. How Long
15. Why Worry
16. Whistle Theme (with live whistle from MK ;) ) / Wild Theme
-
I must say that the whole thing has never interested me in the slightest.
-
Oooh imagine MK doing a MTV Unplugged-like concert :D :D
My (realistic?) set for that, just MK and Richard and Glenn:
No Guy? It seems to me MK cannot sing and play a song LIVE without Guy.
-
Just read this topic and found this acoustic session: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DwMsHwEBbgo
-
Oooh imagine MK doing a MTV Unplugged-like concert :D :D
My (realistic?) set for that, just MK and Richard and Glenn:
No Guy? It seems to me MK cannot sing and play a song LIVE without Guy.
Guy will be in the audience, enjoying a cup of tea :lol :thumbsup