A Mark In Time
Previous Albums => Shangri-La (2004) => Topic started by: ChrisGlastonbury on February 01, 2023, 08:33:02 PM
-
On the basis that no album is perfect, which track would you leave off Shangri-La if you were trimming?
I'll start: All That Matters. OK, but uneventful
-
On the basis that no album is perfect, which track would you leave off Shangri-La if you were trimming?
I'll start: All That Matters. OK, but uneventful
That's one of my faves, and became even more meaningful after I became a father, so no dice.
I would remove Don't Crash the Ambulance. It's vaguely amusing but doesn't make sense and doesn't stand up to repeated listens.
-
I enjoy them all, so wouldn't remove any!
-
Whoop De Doo
-
Sony.
Can't stand it, and don't know why this is the one Mark chose to play live most !
-
OK, if I really, really have to leave one off it would be Donegan's Gone.
-
Whoop De Doo
One of my very favourite of all his songs!
-
I love Shangri-La and it vies with Sailing To Philadelphia as my favourite of Mark's solo albums. I think Sailing To Philadelphia on balance has the stronger set of songs and greater stylistic variety, but Shangri-La is a more cohesive album with a set of songs that complement each other. However, there is one song that in my opinion does not fit well with the others and it's Don't Crash The Ambulance. I think I get what he was trying to go for with this track, but it isn't quite funny enough to compensate for the unpleasantness of the lyrics and it is out of place tonally with the rest of the album, making for a jarring closing track. I usually end the album with Donegan's Gone, which makes for a surprisingly effective closer as it picks up the energy somewhat after two very slow tracks.
-
Shangri-La is one of Mark's best work and I love it.
-
I love Shangri-La and it vies with Sailing To Philadelphia as my favourite of Mark's solo albums. I think Sailing To Philadelphia on balance has the stronger set of songs and greater stylistic variety, but Shangri-La is a more cohesive album with a set of songs that complement each other. However, there is one song that in my opinion does not fit well with the others and it's Don't Crash The Ambulance. I think I get what he was trying to go for with this track, but it isn't quite funny enough to compensate for the unpleasantness of the lyrics and it is out of place tonally with the rest of the album, making for a jarring closing track. I usually end the album with Donegan's Gone, which makes for a surprisingly effective closer as it picks up the energy somewhat after two very slow tracks.
My thoughts exactly, stated more eloquently than I could manage :)
-
shangri la.
find it boring as R&J
if i need to go to the toiler twice during a Knopfler show, i would wait for these 2 songs
LOVE the rest of the album.
-
shangri la.
find it boring as R&J
if i need to go to the toiler twice during a Knopfler show, i would wait for these 2 songs
LOVE the rest of the album.
If you don't need to pee just become a coke addict.