'Questionable'? Surely this is trolling? Can you please let us know next time you do something for a good cause so we can point out all its flaws and inconsistencies....
You are more than welcome. I just thought about bringing together 60 pianists to play Sergei Rachmaninoff's Piano Concerto No. 3 for charity, it should be a lot of fun.
So what about Guitars on the beach?
https://www.daysoftheyear.com/days/guitars-on-the-beach
Over 2000 people playing together for good causes. By your logic we should be criticising it because it sounds rubbish. Should we question the motives of the organisers?
This discussion reminds me when Ralph Fiennes was asked about how it felt to put on nazi uniform on the set of Schindler's List for the first time. His answer was: It felt great, it's a very well-made, comfortable Hugo Boss uniform, you feel powerful wearing it. Now, is Ralph Fiennes a Nazi for saying that?
No, he just answers the question and separates the terms Nazi uniform from their doings. Likewise, you can look at this new Going Home version from standpoint of independent creation and a charity effort. As a charity effort, it rocks. As a creation it likely sucks, this is all I wanted to say.
Nice evasion there. You know what people say about debate/discussion when the Nazis are mentioned.
But you said a lot more than that. You questioned the motives of 'the army of millionaires' involved and claimed that this was 'a music business project'.
I still want to know, would you stand at Guitars on the beach, or a hurricane relief benefit, or even the TCT concert series itself and criticise?
I attended last years TCT and much of the music wasn't particularly to my taste but I wouldn't dream of criticising what they were doing, not for one minute....